Dispute Summary
| Field |
Value |
| Dispute ID |
0xcc9098e6829e20ad56e23581a4e901c0426053d4909f021f87759f273b597fd7 |
| Allocation ID |
0xcfd4ffc387051b6889231ff30536d87997f2731f |
| Subgraph |
QmVcBWJZQNYKJpd1Vx9BLrgjvxnmuev7JhD2HvLVn4XBy6 |
| Network |
avalanche |
| POI Block Number |
74,472,074 |
| Closed At Epoch |
1121 |
| Charter Type |
Horizon (GIP-0085) |
Disputed POI
| Field |
Value |
| Indexer |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
| Operator |
0xc4e706f488751cecc0a184e5a7acff5f35b0d5bb |
| Submitted POI |
0xc3304988af4eb4b1486e0c87d71050887c14891b10966a785c8ba356bffcaf53 |
| Expected POI |
0x0e92763b56750809a39c5eadde849a7c5d51efe0beaa30959f46ad6759c4c3ef |
| Result |
Mismatch |
Corroborating Evidence
No other indexer closed an allocation at POI block 74,472,074 on this subgraph. However, the disputed indexer’s own allocation history demonstrates the subgraph produces correct, verifiable POIs in this block range. The disputed indexer matched at blocks immediately before the mismatch (74,282,550 and 74,154,903) and after it (75,381,882), and multiple other indexers matched at blocks spanning the full range:
| Indexer |
Block |
Result |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
74,154,903 |
Match |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
74,282,550 |
Match |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
74,472,074 |
Mismatch |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
75,381,882 |
Match |
0xfc842f81490dcb37e82d416b2d28327dfb24ba9a |
73,780,735 |
Match |
0x35917c0eb91d2e21bef40940d028940484230c06 |
75,174,859 |
Match |
0xf00f7157fa8fd0420b87956d46058a16b2f23adc |
75,174,859 |
Match |
0x2f09092aacd80196fc984908c5a9a7ab3ee4f1ce |
75,174,859 |
Match |
0xfc842f81490dcb37e82d416b2d28327dfb24ba9a |
75,594,156 |
Match |
The subgraph was being correctly indexed by multiple independent indexers throughout this period. The mismatch is isolated to the disputed indexer at this specific block.
Cross-Subgraph Analysis
The disputed indexer also indexes two other Avalanche subgraphs: QmeuzzdgrN9mjAYQqVENLDRWtREV7wDMGVEthhg1sY4xdu and QmWFbXcvxqD39BjzJ72WwF4fe8ZGH2Z25ZcrF7onCPPBpr. I verified their POIs on these subgraphs and found a correlated pattern of mismatches.
The disputed indexer mismatched on all three subgraphs at the same block, then recovered on all of them simultaneously:
| POI Block |
QmVcBWJZQNYKJpd1Vx9BLrgjvxnmuev7JhD2HvLVn4XBy6 (this dispute) |
QmeuzzdgrN9mjAYQqVENLDRWtREV7wDMGVEthhg1sY4xdu |
QmWFbXcvxqD39BjzJ72WwF4fe8ZGH2Z25ZcrF7onCPPBpr |
| 73,333,339 |
Mismatch |
– |
Mismatch |
| 74,472,074 |
Mismatch |
Mismatch |
Mismatch |
| 75,381,882 |
Match |
Match |
Match |
On QmeuzzdgrN9mjAYQqVENLDRWtREV7wDMGVEthhg1sY4xdu, the disputed indexer is the only indexer with any mismatch. Three other indexers (0x3e1536fc83cd5bed83a521a26034ff3e59c6a7c4, 0x8cc22436ba6f07a4d5dd2043e3109267eee5aab8, 0x0a015d9e17d3978164486473a2ddbb654418db07 ← self) all matched across 7 allocations spanning blocks 72,836,707 to 75,811,870.
On QmWFbXcvxqD39BjzJ72WwF4fe8ZGH2Z25ZcrF7onCPPBpr, four other indexers (0x53dbbc9d916b1840a2c4c26b150ba2e13f36e10f, 0x0a015d9e17d3978164486473a2ddbb654418db07, 0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4, 0x3e1536fc83cd5bed83a521a26034ff3e59c6a7c4) all matched at blocks surrounding the disputed indexer’s mismatches. 0x53dbbc9d916b1840a2c4c26b150ba2e13f36e10f matched at block 74,537,393 – immediately after the mismatch at 74,472,074.
I do not believe that 3 seemingly independent subgraphs with different code, different mappings, different entities, etc… simply break and then recover in unison, if not for infra issues, unless there is another factor I have not considered? The shared variable across all three subgraphs with mismatching PoI’s is the indexer’s own infrastructure/RPC. This pattern indicates to me that the mismatches originate from the indexer’s setup rather than from any individual subgraph.
GDR-48, covers a separate Legacy-era allocation by the same indexer on the same subgraph at block 73,333,339.
Full Verification Data
All closed allocations on QmVcBWJZQNYKJpd1Vx9BLrgjvxnmuev7JhD2HvLVn4XBy6 verified against my graph-node:
| Indexer |
Block |
Submitted POI |
My Calculated POI |
Result |
0xf00f7157fa8fd0420b87956d46058a16b2f23adc |
77,114,939 |
0xdc2fb880...988993 |
0xdc2fb880...988993 |
Match |
0x2f09092aacd80196fc984908c5a9a7ab3ee4f1ce |
77,114,939 |
0x78b90da2...3fb7ad |
0x78b90da2...3fb7ad |
Match |
0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4 |
77,039,126 |
0xa303d679...3a547c |
0xa303d679...3a547c |
Match |
0x35917c0eb91d2e21bef40940d028940484230c06 |
76,732,196 |
0x5d771d61...5bf8a7 |
0x5d771d61...5bf8a7 |
Match |
0xfc842f81490dcb37e82d416b2d28327dfb24ba9a |
76,238,053 |
0xbebfa124...8bc0d8 |
0xbebfa124...8bc0d8 |
Match |
0x35917c0eb91d2e21bef40940d028940484230c06 |
76,238,053 |
0x35822fe7...e7a276 |
0x35822fe7...e7a276 |
Match |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
76,167,145 |
0xb90bffcf...03c775 |
0xb90bffcf...03c775 |
Match |
0xfc842f81490dcb37e82d416b2d28327dfb24ba9a |
76,095,560 |
0x740ad7e5...4e3730 |
0x740ad7e5...4e3730 |
Match |
0x35917c0eb91d2e21bef40940d028940484230c06 |
76,095,560 |
0xf708d520...e34264 |
0xf708d520...e34264 |
Match |
0xfc842f81490dcb37e82d416b2d28327dfb24ba9a |
75,594,156 |
0x0014bde9...712827 |
0x0014bde9...712827 |
Match |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
75,381,882 |
0x1b1b097f...79e13f |
0x1b1b097f...79e13f |
Match |
0x35917c0eb91d2e21bef40940d028940484230c06 |
75,239,491 |
0xb91dbfbc...f216e9 |
0xb91dbfbc...f216e9 |
Match |
0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4 |
75,239,491 |
0xaff30f4b...1aaa13 |
0xa3d1867d...607b4e |
Mismatch |
0xf00f7157fa8fd0420b87956d46058a16b2f23adc |
75,174,859 |
0xf0fea642...71868a |
0xf0fea642...71868a |
Match |
0x2f09092aacd80196fc984908c5a9a7ab3ee4f1ce |
75,174,859 |
0x7f2e3495...a85e49 |
0x7f2e3495...a85e49 |
Match |
0x35917c0eb91d2e21bef40940d028940484230c06 |
75,174,859 |
0xcdb7683f...cfe67f |
0xcdb7683f...cfe67f |
Match |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
74,472,074 |
0xc3304988...fcaf53 |
0x0e92763b...c4c3ef |
Mismatch |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
74,282,550 |
0xbc5bcba3...600872 |
0xbc5bcba3...600872 |
Match |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
74,154,903 |
0xa2bcfef4...8adcaa |
0xa2bcfef4...8adcaa |
Match |
0xfc842f81490dcb37e82d416b2d28327dfb24ba9a |
73,780,735 |
0x6bb41cc7...9bc773 |
0x6bb41cc7...9bc773 |
Match |
0xf00f7157fa8fd0420b87956d46058a16b2f23adc |
73,461,249 |
0xe8722e2a...04b2b9 |
0xe8722e2a...04b2b9 |
Match |
0x2f09092aacd80196fc984908c5a9a7ab3ee4f1ce |
73,461,249 |
0x658d1135...060a30 |
0x658d1135...060a30 |
Match |
0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4 |
73,397,298 |
0x0dfb65e8...f08b2d |
0x0dfb65e8...f08b2d |
Match |
0xfc842f81490dcb37e82d416b2d28327dfb24ba9a |
73,333,339 |
0xc9735e98...08b459 |
0xc9735e98...08b459 |
Match |
0xf00f7157fa8fd0420b87956d46058a16b2f23adc |
73,333,339 |
0x3610f2d3...64358e |
0x3610f2d3...64358e |
Match |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
73,333,339 |
0xe46fb807...a0f9cf |
0xce1fd638...3037f2 |
Mismatch |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
72,955,253 |
0x5f20a938...76a08d |
0x5f20a938...76a08d |
Match |
0xfc842f81490dcb37e82d416b2d28327dfb24ba9a |
72,895,891 |
0xcf41bfa5...70f341 |
0xcf41bfa5...70f341 |
Match |
0x2f09092aacd80196fc984908c5a9a7ab3ee4f1ce |
72,895,891 |
0xc71c7484...997218 |
0xc71c7484...997218 |
Match |
0x35917c0eb91d2e21bef40940d028940484230c06 |
72,601,656 |
0xab79be77...e8666c |
0xab79be77...e8666c |
Match |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
72,601,656 |
0x43db2a4a...97c1ec |
0x43db2a4a...97c1ec |
Match |
0x3f74870f80ff7449fe4c6ff257da5fa72734c970 |
72,089,542 |
0x3bb8031e...e5adab |
0x3bb8031e...e5adab |
Match |
0xdec965f0604125be05cd8a136c85d02ef344d61a |
72,089,542 |
0x77bb5742...77f52e |
0x77bb5742...77f52e |
Match |
0xdeb712db301285ed483ef9e02dd08a1980f273f1 |
72,089,542 |
0x08266ecb...4eb24d |
0x08266ecb...4eb24d |
Match |
0x6f3ce93a09f30f18d728d2364268b5fe9444b89e |
72,089,542 |
0x84a199de...f80317 |
0x84a199de...f80317 |
Match |
0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4 |
72,032,972 |
0xb16ed24a...fb65de |
0xb16ed24a...fb65de |
Match |
0xf00f7157fa8fd0420b87956d46058a16b2f23adc |
71,709,769 |
0x70c82855...cbb143 |
0x70c82855...cbb143 |
Match |
0xdecba5154aab37ae5e381a19f804f3af4d1bcbb5 |
71,709,769 |
0x3032e418...76bd24 |
0x3032e418...76bd24 |
Match |
Closing Transaction
| Field |
Value |
| Arbitrum Block Hash |
0xf4cf06d6cf906cce7d404c4c808cfeac161e53e4df64bcb3acbea5761758979e |
| Arbiscan Link |
View on Arbiscan |
Final note
I am happy to provide any additional information the Arbitration Team requires, including the full POI verification data for the supporting subgraphs referenced in the cross-subgraph analysis.