Update: The Arbitration Charter GIP has been updated based on a lot of the feedback in the above thread. It can still be found on the zerim/arbitration-charter branch of the GIPs repo. Looking forward to getting your feedback on the changes.
For reference, here are the recent commits (can’t wait until Radicle adds PR support):
5236bff (HEAD -> zerim/arbitration-charter, rad/zerim/arbitration-charter) arbitration-charter: Add items to future work based on community feedback
5fcac46 arbitration-charter: allow indexers to collect indexing rewards right after subgraph fails
90a2906 arbitration-charter: add "future work" section
9dd6b6b arbitration-charter: add clauses based on community input
326f8ec arbitration charter: Add missing links to forum discussions
665dbc6 Add proposal for arbitration charter