Request for Information about Disputes #GDR-55

Governance & GIPs Arbitration
1

The Arbitrators are contacting Indexer address 0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4 and fisherman 0x0a015d9e17d3978164486473a2ddbb654418db07 for a new dispute filed in the protocol.

Dispute ID: 0x81596e98d17b2073db46d2f9f687e62f52ce178b7915285422e9dd51c691eb20
Allocation: 0xd5d4e381f971e288b175bf8defa70345e6cd15bc
Subgraph: QmXhWmYZyEr8PGEic8F739wVqvMYxHLD7jke69RXmwQU95

Fisherman, could you share the insights or data you gathered that led to you filing the dispute? Please provide all relevant information and records about the open dispute. This will likely include POIs generated for the affected subgraph(s).

About the Procedure

The Arbitration Charter regulates the arbitration process. You can find it in Radicle project ID rad:git:hnrkrhnth6afcc6mnmtokbp4h9575fgrhzbay or at GIP-0009: Arbitration Charter.

Please use this forum for all communications.

Arbitration Team

2

Dispute Summary

Field Value
Allocation ID 0xd5d4e381f971e288b175bf8defa70345e6cd15bc
POI Block Number 87628775
Submitted POI 0x348e491069d0394fe0162666c0dbcb65747309c566bd2feaaed38a6442c0b28f
Expected POI 0xe8e3ae5bf8902694f2c51ef7e6e0ada0d65e501eae68594d7dd2f672c0278bd3
Result Mismatch
Indexer 0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4
Operator 0x4ecb19a2ac49c5decfa5e65b6669c7e7fab5da9d
Subgraph QmXhWmYZyEr8PGEic8F739wVqvMYxHLD7jke69RXmwQU95
Arbitrum Block Hash 0x4154a258c01f3af8db58830900b6a3bbe6341365452678b99046dc4335450a9a
Arbiscan Transaction Hash 0x0ee3d0249107fef47cd389f57b41e51bd0f7c22c263aa2468d39730d0056ae1d
Network avalanche
Closed At Epoch 1286
Charter Type Horizon (GIP-0085)

Corroborating Evidence

3 other indexers closed allocations on the same subgraph at the same POI block number (87,628,775), and each submitted a POI that matches what my graph-node independently computed:

Indexer Operator Allocation ID Submitted POI My Calculated POI Result
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 0xb3a0ddf05b7b89af588173a92f8c0089aa5a72fd 0x8456af762861c4d7b7b49c7f0ebfa3fb18f83b6a 0xf7c45352656e0d8c383b5215de09afac6ca227facda67dea867d71fd750cfc98 0xf7c45352656e0d8c383b5215de09afac6ca227facda67dea867d71fd750cfc98 Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 0x8221f968c7bf43938f262bb2ecb70f8e0dbf06d2 0x9bb49c87c068c1ab7a9d69e9982d2051d8b3adc7 0x703dbdebfbe8a469d44fbc413dc974726699aa6c0638edd1f677b52b6b8a75c7 0x703dbdebfbe8a469d44fbc413dc974726699aa6c0638edd1f677b52b6b8a75c7 Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 0x008847c358253ac18ae6bf787954d9fc57e87e1f 0x3d62d6139fe9e27aeadc9badeb79310027958d6d 0x5692965e81b909052d8d2f3406051ca18fd0e695cc836efdd94ef2967794aeb4 0x5692965e81b909052d8d2f3406051ca18fd0e695cc836efdd94ef2967794aeb4 Match

This corroborating evidence demonstrates that:

  1. The subgraph can be correctly indexed to block 87,628,775 (as proven by 3 other indexers each submitting a matching POI)
  2. The disputed indexer’s POI does not match what other indexers and my graph-node computed
  3. This suggests the mismatch is not caused by a determinism issue in the subgraph

Additional Evidence

I verified all other closed allocations on this subgraph against my graph-node. The disputed indexer has 3 presently disputable mismatches on this subgraph:

Indexer Block Submitted POI My Calculated POI Result
0x2b3c7d1ef5fdfc0557934019c531d3e70d6200ae 89,608,669 0x24d45dae545037b04b3b898ac1baf7a14398abf872aba69723f9f3a80fc0a5b3 0x24d45dae545037b04b3b898ac1baf7a14398abf872aba69723f9f3a80fc0a5b3 Match
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 89,608,669 0xc0c1b80abd4f4a80ced36247b0d9d6e7724216c4b234ec525d0d78157fac0a51 0xc0c1b80abd4f4a80ced36247b0d9d6e7724216c4b234ec525d0d78157fac0a51 Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 89,358,786 0x74d59f97031cf3f27b0cda4123eb928998f8564013d338392d2767936908fc5f 0x74d59f97031cf3f27b0cda4123eb928998f8564013d338392d2767936908fc5f Match
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 89,273,810 0x1d34d2cae99c7347dde48b68a0327aa122b3d1f423826996da6ea4df014bc6be 0x1d34d2cae99c7347dde48b68a0327aa122b3d1f423826996da6ea4df014bc6be Match
0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4 89,189,174 0x582764ed5cb7fecc44459b0de529320305e1a9231ade19e215cb3d072313ac48 0x3e53a80835ff71da4d4afa8dde63296ce8ce05101ba24971df0bfb937dc8d52a Mismatch
0x2b3c7d1ef5fdfc0557934019c531d3e70d6200ae 89,189,174 0x274605377b1a30383578c7ad29c537638d5f8f916e9217e86767f7f1471ad31e 0x274605377b1a30383578c7ad29c537638d5f8f916e9217e86767f7f1471ad31e Match
0x2f09092aacd80196fc984908c5a9a7ab3ee4f1ce 89,042,373 0x9a61b5307d72a06fc8651e0f4b2880234945bdac87a8e42d9c88dcd8eec2f545 0x9a61b5307d72a06fc8651e0f4b2880234945bdac87a8e42d9c88dcd8eec2f545 Match
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 88,833,625 0xb40727852336a9c8f6f323721fa0b6c54fefea062eb7cc82b2e9a775e5a4f70f 0xb40727852336a9c8f6f323721fa0b6c54fefea062eb7cc82b2e9a775e5a4f70f Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 88,762,723 0x5ffcd18453863c3ab0e783160d397b14f68f517458984fde506ead473e21a0e1 0x5ffcd18453863c3ab0e783160d397b14f68f517458984fde506ead473e21a0e1 Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 88,762,723 0x503250f52824d5a25180583d7131e9a07c7524da54768a7089414e76abb45e34 0x503250f52824d5a25180583d7131e9a07c7524da54768a7089414e76abb45e34 Match
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 88,696,211 0xfac4f82a9f70d1cd8b1370f52f150f11d5baf3b7ff0ffe95e88dd00887fbd356 0xfac4f82a9f70d1cd8b1370f52f150f11d5baf3b7ff0ffe95e88dd00887fbd356 Match
0xa6ff993e0f6253f1b7f55c873577a2f0f0ceb325 88,625,436 0xdb62a17243d6fb9bd22b25363b17e188a5d1b6cba6bcef14f6c92faa91fa3ed1 0xdb62a17243d6fb9bd22b25363b17e188a5d1b6cba6bcef14f6c92faa91fa3ed1 Match
0x2b3c7d1ef5fdfc0557934019c531d3e70d6200ae 88,554,427 0xa503d7f5ed6085ca694537eb2f664a51ca7570596b4712285ca41f8cb2749285 0xa503d7f5ed6085ca694537eb2f664a51ca7570596b4712285ca41f8cb2749285 Match
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 88,554,427 0x1d14bef801c839465494449679b6724db082c4f951e04300000e76b36ceb259e 0x1d14bef801c839465494449679b6724db082c4f951e04300000e76b36ceb259e Match
0xe13840a2e92e0cb17a246609b432d0fa2e418774 88,416,068 0xa410cda380812a3ba40006de2974ff32db8cd6915722220edfcfc6acc65916aa 0xa410cda380812a3ba40006de2974ff32db8cd6915722220edfcfc6acc65916aa Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 88,345,263 0xef0af8a9947cf2fce1d535695d02cd1ee547703c12cdc82092d5077f577fe070 0xef0af8a9947cf2fce1d535695d02cd1ee547703c12cdc82092d5077f577fe070 Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 88,275,409 0x26b9874f8f787bc3edbc01c028c2cac0f82f0f56bd8651e696b742cc63bb6be0 0x26b9874f8f787bc3edbc01c028c2cac0f82f0f56bd8651e696b742cc63bb6be0 Match
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 88,275,409 0x6cc21ee9bc974f1c0ed760d99acda50323e50479e002bb8ff992ba5b9fc0d144 0x6cc21ee9bc974f1c0ed760d99acda50323e50479e002bb8ff992ba5b9fc0d144 Match
0xa6ff993e0f6253f1b7f55c873577a2f0f0ceb325 88,205,712 0x2e7b2e3d0e4b77db29561bee6acb2daf8a04023a278df130752a3bde0010f9d5 0x2e7b2e3d0e4b77db29561bee6acb2daf8a04023a278df130752a3bde0010f9d5 Match
0x2b3c7d1ef5fdfc0557934019c531d3e70d6200ae 88,135,553 0x8acfbd8f7ba5eb0570ec239d3c73ccf1ab53670b47f940ee65d06319802bf7b2 0x8acfbd8f7ba5eb0570ec239d3c73ccf1ab53670b47f940ee65d06319802bf7b2 Match
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 88,135,553 0x101e21cf1da69ebab3bd56cda316f0c11af412c931e957f7fb8d1051b69f61c8 0x101e21cf1da69ebab3bd56cda316f0c11af412c931e957f7fb8d1051b69f61c8 Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 88,053,329 0xc7c9c29a52ea81fa705626e9c97ce3c0f131146a2cd49107cf87fce6aa792eba 0xc7c9c29a52ea81fa705626e9c97ce3c0f131146a2cd49107cf87fce6aa792eba Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 88,053,329 0xbe4ebc4f952d83e189347d9b2813d5b061faef05d4116117b0046b127222017b 0xbe4ebc4f952d83e189347d9b2813d5b061faef05d4116117b0046b127222017b Match
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 88,053,329 0x42207a426d1b02bb8de603399b488ba0efaaa2252b01685202eecea31751781d 0x42207a426d1b02bb8de603399b488ba0efaaa2252b01685202eecea31751781d Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 87,713,907 0xee96196c303a7150e450ca3f915ea6f0af106d404e4946377d4a663735c34331 0xee96196c303a7150e450ca3f915ea6f0af106d404e4946377d4a663735c34331 Match
0x2b3c7d1ef5fdfc0557934019c531d3e70d6200ae 87,713,907 0x46285bc0d9e18ffa4d4505abe6c77ba9a3a1ed8bd4b5403c77e779dd16accb1e 0x46285bc0d9e18ffa4d4505abe6c77ba9a3a1ed8bd4b5403c77e779dd16accb1e Match
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 87,628,775 0xf7c45352656e0d8c383b5215de09afac6ca227facda67dea867d71fd750cfc98 0xf7c45352656e0d8c383b5215de09afac6ca227facda67dea867d71fd750cfc98 Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 87,628,775 0x703dbdebfbe8a469d44fbc413dc974726699aa6c0638edd1f677b52b6b8a75c7 0x703dbdebfbe8a469d44fbc413dc974726699aa6c0638edd1f677b52b6b8a75c7 Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 87,628,775 0x5692965e81b909052d8d2f3406051ca18fd0e695cc836efdd94ef2967794aeb4 0x5692965e81b909052d8d2f3406051ca18fd0e695cc836efdd94ef2967794aeb4 Match
0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4 87,628,775 0x348e491069d0394fe0162666c0dbcb65747309c566bd2feaaed38a6442c0b28f 0xe8e3ae5bf8902694f2c51ef7e6e0ada0d65e501eae68594d7dd2f672c0278bd3 Mismatch
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 87,543,561 0x24fb275a087888234d5ae61e5e5d05cf7cc4b0f692ebd9ab1e5ade94b6ef7b8e 0x24fb275a087888234d5ae61e5e5d05cf7cc4b0f692ebd9ab1e5ade94b6ef7b8e Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 87,458,993 0xa4820d9f77ae9d8b6c1f3c6083ac424214cef1bcbc94f8b775af82fdd914aaec 0xa4820d9f77ae9d8b6c1f3c6083ac424214cef1bcbc94f8b775af82fdd914aaec Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 87,213,955 0x39a32191625775030538a201660415ea451fcf0c2eef7d19ad5e9542ace3cbc4 0x39a32191625775030538a201660415ea451fcf0c2eef7d19ad5e9542ace3cbc4 Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 87,213,955 0xb2eacf6492da22e10882124ad4ff45a7d466a7c0323dc38508ba8b4084ea8acd 0xb2eacf6492da22e10882124ad4ff45a7d466a7c0323dc38508ba8b4084ea8acd Match
0xa6ff993e0f6253f1b7f55c873577a2f0f0ceb325 87,132,661 0x2e3264732c713c494c1840423e7ef5eac00b8bd4f798ea87b0ef423e42c6ecaf 0x2e3264732c713c494c1840423e7ef5eac00b8bd4f798ea87b0ef423e42c6ecaf Match
0x2b3c7d1ef5fdfc0557934019c531d3e70d6200ae 87,132,661 0xd75caec8a58171e953709f5bf32682dacc1f575294f64e24e41a5bef12c19669 0xd75caec8a58171e953709f5bf32682dacc1f575294f64e24e41a5bef12c19669 Match
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 87,048,560 0x4db2064a854b8c9d901f24afc8d04a6ebac84e88937c8b494594bba5f71e970c 0x4db2064a854b8c9d901f24afc8d04a6ebac84e88937c8b494594bba5f71e970c Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 87,048,560 0x527ab5f691e76d671ef77b2fa5836c86338053cae5557c13e5fb12cb8fc0c2be 0x527ab5f691e76d671ef77b2fa5836c86338053cae5557c13e5fb12cb8fc0c2be Match
0x2f09092aacd80196fc984908c5a9a7ab3ee4f1ce 86,879,263 0xc4495697c9dfd85db0db1fe6031ef6ed1f2a6dee0f582ca4ce43be9ee9f76c16 0xc4495697c9dfd85db0db1fe6031ef6ed1f2a6dee0f582ca4ce43be9ee9f76c16 Match
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 86,879,263 0xdbf47a2fb389cbd60fa5aea7b22d691994684b7f22724b5cbd19db0eaf4c1357 0xdbf47a2fb389cbd60fa5aea7b22d691994684b7f22724b5cbd19db0eaf4c1357 Match
0xe13840a2e92e0cb17a246609b432d0fa2e418774 86,879,263 0xc1cd4f09a901b13b0ae0cf346d447383fbd2b1518a0abbdff1c07a2b852dc113 0xc1cd4f09a901b13b0ae0cf346d447383fbd2b1518a0abbdff1c07a2b852dc113 Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 86,548,127 0x625d46b379f84224fcc995d99b754cc22b1a054f4ccb92ba419bd30836473fd8 0x625d46b379f84224fcc995d99b754cc22b1a054f4ccb92ba419bd30836473fd8 Match
0xa6ff993e0f6253f1b7f55c873577a2f0f0ceb325 86,548,127 0xd0e4e2eea38bd9b07439b1b4704cb9b58a3bc76ce8dc8d5ddf550119eeaa2928 0xd0e4e2eea38bd9b07439b1b4704cb9b58a3bc76ce8dc8d5ddf550119eeaa2928 Match
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 86,387,793 0x29e6a72becbc160cc5e0c1d495ddbd3d03d81aa7832f8574f55d85f1bf653f56 0x29e6a72becbc160cc5e0c1d495ddbd3d03d81aa7832f8574f55d85f1bf653f56 Match
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 86,304,992 0xc6162e2e7a00d58eb6d41ed14ef1c92010fb6ae222d460708dd9f321920b172c 0xc6162e2e7a00d58eb6d41ed14ef1c92010fb6ae222d460708dd9f321920b172c Match
0x2b3c7d1ef5fdfc0557934019c531d3e70d6200ae 86,304,992 0x363a98993a94beffd25f34bfc8950207c5ac9fcc18f442fd25ba6149adc89acd 0x363a98993a94beffd25f34bfc8950207c5ac9fcc18f442fd25ba6149adc89acd Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 86,304,992 0x3b9ed1050ba561d1851ef76ee198031aa6e36f5ed594d3ee9dbbb01ea25963d3 0x3b9ed1050ba561d1851ef76ee198031aa6e36f5ed594d3ee9dbbb01ea25963d3 Match
0xe6de2325ef1aac1f058fae59d3c38a472f569846 86,053,456 0x8abb63dd423f60b888e159d5011c6a7bd6d3233210d28d657409c76daa7bcc39 0x8abb63dd423f60b888e159d5011c6a7bd6d3233210d28d657409c76daa7bcc39 Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 85,969,361 0xdd6a733f16cbfd79a4c375bd5c5aa48a30a6aa517a0fbfc8cc1b518541770df9 0xdd6a733f16cbfd79a4c375bd5c5aa48a30a6aa517a0fbfc8cc1b518541770df9 Match
0xa6ff993e0f6253f1b7f55c873577a2f0f0ceb325 85,969,361 0x34265ac13e8605064c0ffba300849b5f382609dd472920752ae1dbfb14e1455d 0x34265ac13e8605064c0ffba300849b5f382609dd472920752ae1dbfb14e1455d Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 85,884,121 0x3cde04876d371c41adf92583c87a431c213fa18ff5e9790215dd0e1ff95ca04a 0x3cde04876d371c41adf92583c87a431c213fa18ff5e9790215dd0e1ff95ca04a Match
0xf92f430dd8567b0d466358c79594ab58d919a6d4 85,884,121 0x62e29d700c77fbc6557ed14e277ad1ba950d2425db311d14184c112b95b3982d 0x9b3ceb6321be1cc7ae30a1bbb7247c8b75ebfafc28d1a941709a5217415d345c Mismatch
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 85,884,121 0xd331148fdf3b6f581b4453c79a071cc84e51567436609eecffef916bdb86f19d 0xd331148fdf3b6f581b4453c79a071cc84e51567436609eecffef916bdb86f19d Match
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 85,798,998 0x18926698f2604611d03c95d900de49b15648b60c061f3a8461243e335409ae8a 0x18926698f2604611d03c95d900de49b15648b60c061f3a8461243e335409ae8a Match
0x2b3c7d1ef5fdfc0557934019c531d3e70d6200ae 85,798,998 0x1aed2fe75010802f1c537af19bc7b14fe373934240fe747a45417dfa37bc9e77 0x1aed2fe75010802f1c537af19bc7b14fe373934240fe747a45417dfa37bc9e77 Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 85,756,930 0xbae09858eb515c20152c84b6fa5368c88328de25342bafa79544677cf7d84b1a 0xbae09858eb515c20152c84b6fa5368c88328de25342bafa79544677cf7d84b1a Match
0xa6ff993e0f6253f1b7f55c873577a2f0f0ceb325 85,461,857 0x15e1fa80b6a0b9f0210807a65e532314331de737e629a4b87644c6df91cab1b6 0x15e1fa80b6a0b9f0210807a65e532314331de737e629a4b87644c6df91cab1b6 Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 85,461,857 0x1428e7042c5fcc3ae575464b4dd32b08f9dc8a451d6ae33b15651edecc772f52 0x1428e7042c5fcc3ae575464b4dd32b08f9dc8a451d6ae33b15651edecc772f52 Match
0xdc53e62df89fd07b31ed4ff886397b9e7ae4625e 85,377,214 0x38d331e5674e36d0eafa065eb7106b4fe926090de4bd5b9a3ec093f444699ca4 0x38d331e5674e36d0eafa065eb7106b4fe926090de4bd5b9a3ec093f444699ca4 Match
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 85,377,214 0x0c4f3e3c83761a666597398e679414b08c236a92c4bf8c2d131628f1c353a098 0x0c4f3e3c83761a666597398e679414b08c236a92c4bf8c2d131628f1c353a098 Match
0x2b3c7d1ef5fdfc0557934019c531d3e70d6200ae 85,377,214 0xec27dadfd16b27617a33fbb8432990a30d6c154190def018f6a4ba69856e412d 0xec27dadfd16b27617a33fbb8432990a30d6c154190def018f6a4ba69856e412d Match
0xe9e284277648fcdb09b8efc1832c73c09b5ecf59 85,292,430 0x27814148c4c2e9ed6a7a0792501eeaa49c9a4ddb903ea6cae0d6c6614491ccf8 0x27814148c4c2e9ed6a7a0792501eeaa49c9a4ddb903ea6cae0d6c6614491ccf8 Match
0x090f7382f9ea85c733cd501f4d87f16cb5b83ed3 85,292,430 0x5a88d7aed3f14c5c9b688d9648e7a28338706c75c37f38bff6d92eda7664020c 0x5a88d7aed3f14c5c9b688d9648e7a28338706c75c37f38bff6d92eda7664020c Match
0xa6ff993e0f6253f1b7f55c873577a2f0f0ceb325 85,207,904 0xe1deb197aa2db012ede74d35c6e7987d3157385608cd19fd7f57f5cc4fe5d26f 0xe1deb197aa2db012ede74d35c6e7987d3157385608cd19fd7f57f5cc4fe5d26f Match
0x9af3fc811a66dbbca44acce94906d8743f9cf0d0 85,207,904 0x97ae8283a12030bf726af64c48d767692f9f0fd207bd89b10acc8719092e1f7f 0x97ae8283a12030bf726af64c48d767692f9f0fd207bd89b10acc8719092e1f7f Match

Final note

I am happy to provide any additional information the Arbitration Team requires.

3

Hello, indexer here. Thank you for opening this thread — we’ve completed our investigation and can explain the divergence fully.

Summary. The disputed allocation 0xd5d4e381f971e288b175bf8defa70345e6cd15bc (deployment QmXhWmYZyEr8PGEic8F739wVqvMYxHLD7jke69RXmwQU95, Aave v2 Avalanche; disputed POI 0x348e491069d0394fe0162666c0dbcb65747309c566bd2feaaed38a6442c0b28f) was closed automatically by the official indexer-agent, with the POI generated by graph-node from a fully synced, healthy copy. The divergence is caused by a documented determinism bug in official graph-node — not by any manual intervention.

Root cause. graph-node PR #5867 inadvertently changed event.transactionLogIndex to return 0 with geth-style RPC providers. It shipped in v0.38.0 and was reverted in v0.39.1 (fix commit ccd276e6cac5ab2446b6ed3ebc7ccb8d8b28a5b9), whose release notes explicitly cite “duplicate ID errors and POI divergence between indexers”.

This subgraph embeds event.transactionLogIndex in its entity IDs — see getHistoryEntityId, src/utils/id-generation.ts line 13. Every entity written while we ran v0.38.0 (deployed 2025-04-23, upgraded to v0.39.1 on 2025-06-04, per our config git history) therefore carries a divergent ID. For example, at the first divergent block 59392151 (hash 0x9891e2f8da0908e1e54df029cee0bdaa8b131e0bbc5505895f2333ab5a6ad853), the Deposit in tx 0xd3b5ee0833f64ec0b3ef5091fc9762186d5443b3f99aec962fe53820a155bdc2 got ID …:46:0 in our copy versus …:46:46 on other indexers — identical data otherwise. POIs being cumulative, all our subsequent POIs on this deployment differ from consensus.

Evidence available on request:

  • POI bisection pinpointing block 59392151 as the first divergent block;
  • entity-level comparison at that block against other indexers’ public status endpoints (entityChangesInBlock), showing identical data except the transactionLogIndex ID component;
  • indexer-agent db dump showing automatic closure (poi: null in the action queue);
  • poi table dumps and software versions.

Remediation (data already corrected, catch-up in progress). We resynced the affected range from below block 59392151 on graph-node v0.42.1 and verified the re-indexed entities match consensus exactly. This corrected copy is now the active copy for the deployment. It is still catching up to chain head; until it is fully synced we will close any allocation on this deployment with a 0x0 POI, and subsequent closures will submit POIs from the clean copy.

Note: This was a 50 GRT allocation, which earned 0.33 GRT in indexing rewards and 2.76 GRT in query fees over its 21-epoch lifetime. There was no economic upside to be gained here from anything but honest indexing.

2 Likes
4

Thanks for the investigation Ellipfra, I verified the above and everything you said checks out, I see no reason to waste arbitrators time with this one, so I withdraw my dispute. Thank you for the detailed investigation above and your remediation steps.

While I’m here I would recommend you to take a look at the subgraph below to check if a similar issue may be at play:

  • QmVcBWJZQNYKJpd1Vx9BLrgjvxnmuev7JhD2HvLVn4XBy6
    • block: 86,387,793
    • submitted poi: 0x7b22a121a10790faf0d4cfeddbf6d227144bb2a9e3112a148675a339737623aa
    • expected poi: 0x73282d4f28fba63f8c749b89775e6b68590b37c371fdf326082a82fce59daa60

I see a few other discrepancies on various other subgraphs, but I’m not as confident in the underlying cause on those and the present signal from other indexers is a lot messier with regards to poi consensus, likely due to determinism issues on the subgraphs.

1 Like
5

To my recollection this is the first time we see that specific class of divergence in the wild. Now that we know that it exists for real, I will be conducting further analysis do determine if other subgraphs are impacted.

As for the subgraph that you mention, a quick analysis suggests that Ellipfra has compatible POIs with P2P, while badcoffee.eth appears to be the outlier. When there are too few indexers on a subgraph it remains very difficult to determine the reference.

6

Thanks @badcoffee and @ellipfra for the investigation on both ends.

Seeing as this is a clear cut case, we’ll move on and draw the dispute so the fisherman gets the deposit back.

1 Like
7

Dispute drawn here: Arbitrum One Transaction Hash: 0x6ada98b920... | Arbitrum One